Skip to content
  • Bretanark
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Contact

Contradictions in the Bible

18 August 2018 by Brent

Reposting from a FaceBook post in 2016

I was forwarded a document containing 101 contradictions in the bible. Having scrutinized half of these, these claims form the following groups:
• Details contradict in older translations only
• Differing witness accounts
• Differing details from one author
• Rounding differences but similar ballpark figure
• Clerical error
• No contradiction – overzealous to discredit the bible

Summary

While the Bible has a few immaterial contradictions, these imply it is not a collaborated fiction. The Bible is the most well preserved historical record, which withstands all contradictory claims from historians, scientists and philosophers.

Conclusions

I had previously claimed that the Bible is the only 100% accurate historical account. As even modern translations include some valid contradictions, I can no longer make this assertion. Generously allowing for 101 contradictory verses, of the 31,102 verses, 202/31,102 = 0.65% are inconsistent, so the Bible is only 99.35% accurate. This in itself is a problem, because if the Bible is not 100% accurate, it casts doubt on its accuracy. I can only conclude that this too is consistent with God’s nature – just as he created the forbidden tree in Eden and Jesus refused to perform a miracle show, God seems to provide opportunities to test our faith. He wants us to work through and mature our faith, and not remain with an infantile understanding.

I was most disturbed by John’s placing Jesus before Pilate around noon when the other gospels place him on the cross at that time and Mark specifying his crucifixion at 9:00am. How could John get this so wrong?
Reflecting on this, it’s really not of theological importance. It proves a lack of collaboration from John to reinforce the lie established with the earlier gospels, which would have been available to him. I’m sure that the early church fathers would have been aware of this when assembling the Bible, but were not concerned about this inconsistency.

We are taught when reading the Bible to only establish doctrine upon the consistency of multiple biblical sources that stand without contradiction. This is extrapolated from Deuteronomy 19:15 “One witness is not enough to convict anyone accused of any crime or offense they may have committed. A matter must be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses.” When the Bible was assembled from thousands of popular and God-inspired writings, this consistency was a primary criteria for the inclusion or exclusion of certain books. It never meant that every excluded writing was heretical – just not useful. Although there were also many other popular writings that were quite fantastic – particularly some which Mohammed included in the Koran surrounding Jesus’ childhood miracles and the deification of Mary.

Details:

Details contradict in older translations only

The beloved King James Bible was written between 1604 and 1611. It was compiled from Latin and Greek translations, for which there were a limited number of hand-written copies in circulation.
Modern Bibles collaborate these sources with many other manuscripts, dozens of which date back to the first centuries. They also use the Dead Sea scrolls, which date back to centuries before Christ.
Due to the limited number of sources available to renaissance translators, they suffer more from translational and clerical error.
I had previously advised against using the King James Translation because the English language has changed so significantly that some expressions are misunderstood e.g. Genesis 2:28’s “replenish” later developed the meaning to re-stock. Its KJV meaning is reflected in modern translations as “fill”. This list of contradictions provides a further reason to prefer a modern translation.
Among my associations, the New International Version is preferred. I have used this to review these contradictions.

Differing witness accounts

Witnesses to an event will produce different accounts. When a story is collaborated, witnesses will use the same wording and agree on some specific minuscule details. In a legal setting, the truth is established by combining the accounts, corresponding common details and refuting erroneous details can by forensics or well established contradictory facts.

Differing details from one author

I can only say you should compare my dad’s stories today with my childhood version. People remember things differently over time. However, the important points remain intact.

Rounding differences but similar ballpark figure

Above I said the Dead Sea scrolls date back to centuries before Christ. I summarized this from “The Scrolls date from around 250 B.C. to 68 A.D”. I was simply being less precise because I felt greater precision would be a distraction from what I was trying to say.

Clerical error

Ezra 2 and Nehemiah 7 provide independent accounts of the number of people returning from exile. Some family subtotals do not match and some are not specified to add up to the agreed 42,360 in total.
I can speculate that perhaps the original handwriting was poor, but I have no problem with these guys simply getting some numbers wrong. More palatably the definition of belonging to a family may have differed or people may have come to a better understanding of their ancestry between the two accounts.

No contradiction

It seems the author of this list has been overzealous in discrediting the Bible – making some claims that are simply not contradictory.
Joshua defeated the King of Jerusalem, but not Jerusalem itself – because he wasn’t in the city at the time.

Details can be found in http://Bretanark.com/Downloads/101-Bible-Contradictions.docx

Post navigation

Previous Post:

The Story of the Bible – Creation

Next Post:

Cavemen

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Brent Clark

Facebook
YouTube
+64 21 068 7860

Singing in tongues

About Brent

As the son of life-long pastors of the Salvation Army, I grew up surrounded by God and solid Bible teaching. Although a professional software engineer, I’ve always been a church musician and am preoccupied with contemplating God and understanding and defending the integrity of the Bible. Brent presents an unusual, provocative perspective.

I hope to leave you with more questions than answers and a desire to seek God.

Search

Recent Posts

  • Worship betrayed Jesus 10 April 2022
  • How does the Ukrainian invasion fit Bible prophecy? 28 February 2022
  • Vaccine conscientious objectors 17 November 2021
  • Prayer for the Holy Spirit 31 October 2021
  • Pharmakeia and “the end is nigh” – lies 29 August 2021
  • To be or not to be together 28 August 2021
  • The Origin of Demons 22 August 2021
  • Repentance 6 August 2021
  • What do I think of Palestine? 3 May 2021
  • “What do u think about gay or lesbian? Are they good or bad, according to Bible?” 26 January 2021
  • Why did God demand the genocide of Canaan? 27 December 2020
  • When will the rapture happen? 26 September 2020
  • The UAE-Israel treaty and end times 4 September 2020
  • Clean and Unclean, and Biblical Law 17 August 2020
  • God is pouring out a new Pentecost over the World 4 August 2020
  • Do Christians believe in reincarnation? 30 July 2020
  • How does Christianity influence culture? 29 July 2020
  • Where does scripture say we shouldn’t judge Satan? 25 July 2020
  • Are governments around the world working together to bring about globalism? 25 July 2020
  • The Blessing 19 July 2020
  • How bad can things get? 8 July 2020
  • The Apostacy 4 July 2020
  • Biblical Future Timelines 18 May 2020
  • The Restrainer 11 May 2020
  • God says “I hate your noisy songs” 10 May 2020
  • The choice between life and choice 8 May 2020
  • Brent’s parable of the Christmas story 6 May 2020
  • An overview of biblical history yet future 27 April 2020
  • Prophecy vs. Prophecy 25 April 2020
  • The Antichrist Prophecies 18 April 2020
  • The climate is changing 17 April 2020
  • Is the Covid-19 Pandemic from God? 3 April 2020
  • Comfort in the pandemic 16 March 2020
  • Mary, Mother of God 11 March 2020
  • Marriage and Sexuality in the Bible 29 February 2020
  • Is Muhammad prophesied in the Bible? 29 February 2020
  • Should we be worshiping on Saturday? 22 February 2020
  • The Tribulation 31 January 2020
  • The Story of Christmas 22 December 2019
  • Who is Jesus? 22 December 2019
  • The parable of the sheep and the goats 11 December 2019
  • Does God curse people? 8 December 2019
  • The parable of the ten virgins 25 November 2019
  • Beware of the Leaven of the Pharisees and the Sadducees 17 November 2019
  • The Division of the Earth 6 October 2019
  • The greatest earthquake 28 September 2019
  • Do Chinese religious writings pre-date Christian writings? 11 September 2019
  • Matthew 24 – Jesus’ response to end times 7 September 2019
  • The Rapture 7 August 2019
  • God’s words of healing 6 July 2019
  • Most people will spend eternity in Hell 27 June 2019
  • “It’s impossible”, they said 23 June 2019
  • Where is Jesus in the Old Testament? 23 June 2019
  • Who is really in control? 21 June 2019
  • What’s with all this apostle stuff? 16 June 2019
  • Who will lead the church into revival? 15 June 2019
  • Man Soup Recipe 5 June 2019
  • What do I think about global warming? 25 May 2019
  • Euthanasia and the anti-smacking bill 24 May 2019
  • Why did God destroy Sodom and Gomorrah? 18 May 2019
  • Why did God destroy the world with Noah’s flood? 11 May 2019
  • What if Jesus returned in 50 years’ time? 10 May 2019
  • As the bad gets badder the good gets gooder 5 May 2019
  • To my Jewish cousins 25 April 2019
  • Ezekiel 38-39 translated into a modern context 23 April 2019
  • Ezekiel 38-39: The Battle of Gog of Magog 31 March 2019
  • The Creation Gap Theory 2 March 2019
  • False False Prophets 9 February 2019
  • Why I believe the Bible is true 6 February 2019
  • The parable of the wheat and the tares 30 January 2019
  • The parable of the net 26 January 2019
  • It’s all about end times 25 January 2019
  • Who do you follow? 19 January 2019
  • We’re different and that’s ok 15 January 2019
  • Jesus healed me from depression instantly 28 December 2018
  • Knowledge 2 December 2018
  • Concerning End Times 17 November 2018
  • In the beginning, the Ruach of God 7 October 2018
  • How does the Bible present 6,000 years? 29 September 2018
  • Dreams 25 September 2018
  • Has Speaking in Tongues Ceased? 13 September 2018
  • Release from Prison 21 August 2018
  • Cavemen 19 August 2018
  • Contradictions in the Bible 18 August 2018
  • The Story of the Bible – Creation 11 August 2018
  • “Our battle is not against flesh and blood” 5 August 2018
  • The Fall 21 July 2018
  • Philip’s Transport 7 July 2018
  • The Bible in a Classroom 1 July 2018
  • Sin 26 May 2018
  • Unborn babies are humans. Humans have a right to live. 16 May 2018
  • Comforting Mothers whose babies have gone before them 13 May 2018
  • Five-fold ministry like Trinity + Parents 12 May 2018
  • God doesn’t care how many people go to Hell 25 April 2018
  • Honour yer Ma & Pa 21 April 2018
  • The Return of Apostles, Prophets and Evangelists 7 April 2018
  • The Show Must NOT Go On 1 April 2018
  • “What do you think about 666 and the mark of the beast?” 25 March 2018
  • Worship Workshop 19 March 2018
  • My Relationship with God 10 March 2018

Archives

© 2022 Blog | WordPress Theme by Superb Themes